Middle-east Arab News Opinion | Asharq Al-awsat

Turkish PM says tapes of talk with son a fabrication | ASHARQ AL-AWSAT English Archive 2005 -2017
Select Page
Media ID: 55329370

Turkey’s Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan greets his supporters as he arrives for a meeting at the Turkish parliament in Ankara February 25, 2014. Erdogan said on Tuesday voice recordings purportedly of him telling his son to dispose of large sums of money on the day news broke of a graft inquiry were a “treacherous attack” on his office. REUTERS/Umit Bektas (TURKEY – Tags: POLITICS BUSINESS TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY)

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan greets his supporters as he arrives for a meeting at the Turkish parliament in Ankara on February 25, 2014. (REUTERS/Umit Bektas)

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan greets his supporters as he arrives for a meeting at the Turkish parliament in Ankara on February 25, 2014. (REUTERS/Umit Bektas)

Ankara, Reuters—Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan accused political rivals of shameless fabrication of a telephone tape of him telling his son to dispose of large sums of money on the day police raided houses in a graft inquiry into his government.

In a dramatic session of parliament after the posting of the 11-minute audio tape on YouTube, Erdoğan said his political enemies had penetrated encrypted state communications.

He did not name the opponents but made it clear he was talking of a network run by a former ally, Islamic cleric Fethullah Gülen.

Supporters of Erdoğan, locked in a power struggle with Gülen, whom he accuses of contriving a graft scandal to topple him, shouted “Tayyip, we came here to die with you” and “stand tall, don’t bow” and “time is on our side”.

“The people don’t believe these lies,” Erdoğan called back to loud cheers and applause from the public gallery.

Growing political uncertainty around the government and its reaction to the tapes, which Reuters could not authenticate, hit Turkish assets amid broader weakness in emerging markets.

Opinion polls taken before Monday’s posting show Erdoğan’s popularity little affected by the corruption scandal which broke on December 17 with the detention of businessmen close to him and three ministers’ sons.

Monday’s tape will prove a further test of that resilience ahead of March local elections.

“They went and made a shameless montage and released it. If you’re going to make it up, there is a moral and decent way of making things up,” Erdoğan said. “They are even listening to the state’s encrypted telephones. That’s how low they are . . . There is no allegation that we cannot answer.”

The “they” cited by Erdoğan was a clear reference to those among the followers of US-based Islamic cleric Gülen he accuses of building a “parallel state” in Turkey, using power in the judiciary and police to undermine him.

“We will reveal one-by-one all the disgraces of the parallel organization and we will make those who walk with them so embarrassed they won’t be able to go out into the street,” Erdoğan said.

The recording is purportedly of Erdoğan and his son, Bilal, discussing how to reduce the funds to “zero” by distributing them among several businessmen.

At one point, the voice supposedly of Bilal says some 30 million euros (40 million dollars) remain to be disposed of.

Government officials said previous such recordings may have been of ministers and businessmen’s voices, but that the conversations were put together from comments taken out of context to give the impression of impropriety.

“They have wiretapped the Prime Minister, they have wiretapped the chief of intelligence, Ministers, many others. They wiretap the phone for 18 months, they listen to you, and then out of the 18 months of wiretapping they take two or three sentences,” said one senior official.

“Can you imagine the stories you can write out of those two or three sentences, with no context, no background?”

Gülen’s Hizmet (Service) organization, which runs a wide network of schools, businesses and media groups, exercises strong influence in the police and judiciary.

The cleric denies government accusations it drew on this network to undermine Erdoğan after a political falling out between the two men.

Erdoğan remains far and away Turkey’s most popular politician.

But the apparent power struggle with Gülen and his purges of the police and judiciary have cast a shadow over what Western powers long vaunted as a prime example of an effective Islamic democracy.

Faruk Loğoğlu, former ambassador to Washington and vice chairman of the main opposition CHP, said he believed there was no question about the authenticity of the recordings, which his party replayed to its deputies at a parliamentary group meeting.

“Saying it is fake doesn’t mean it didn’t take place. What else can he say? . . . In a minimally functioning democracy the first thing the prime minister has to do is resign. He is clinging on to power and that’s the problem. This is probably the tip of the iceberg,” said Loğoğlu.

The recordings appeared two days after Erdogan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) officially began campaigning for March local elections, which will be followed later in the year by presidential polls that could decide Erdoğan’s political future after 11 years in power.

The government has responded to the graft inquiry by dismissing or reassigning thousands of police officers, tightening its control over the appointment of judges and prosecutors, and pushing through a new law that allows the authorities to block access to websites within hours without a prior court order.

Erdoğan, as in the past, suggested a broader conspiracy against Turkey including the “interest rate lobby” of financiers and “the terror lobby.”

“The lobby of those who couldn’t win the people’s support, the mob of losers came together once more on December 17. Now they are saying ‘we are going to rule Turkey,'” he said.

The growing political uncertainty has hit financial markets.

The lira hit two-week lows against the dollar while stocks fell 3 percent.

Timothy Ash, head of emerging markets research at Standard Bank, said Erdoğan was likely to go further on the offensive against those he deems responsible for producing and leaking these tapes.

“This seems to be a battle to the end/death. The Gülenists seem to want to wound Erdoğan below the waterline to undermine the AK Party’s poll performance in March,” Ash wrote in a note.

Social media and video-sharing sites have been awash with leaked recordings presented as evidence of wrongdoing.

As with the latest recordings, Reuters has been unable to verify their authenticity.