Middle-east Arab News Opinion | Asharq Al-awsat

Italy’s top court begins crucial Berlusconi case hearing | ASHARQ AL-AWSAT English Archive 2005 -2017
Select Page
Media ID: 55311743

Franco Coppi (C), a lawyer of former Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, leaves the Court of Cassation building, in central Rome, 30 July 2013. (EPA/ANGELO CARCONI)

Franco Coppi (C), a lawyer of former Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, leaves the Court of Cassation building, in central Rome, 30 July 2013. (EPA/ANGELO CARCONI)

Franco Coppi (C), a lawyer of former Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, leaves the Court of Cassation building, in central Rome, 30 July 2013. (EPA/ANGELO CARCONI)

Rome, Reuters—Italy’s supreme court heard on Tuesday Silvio Berlusconi’s last appeal against a jail sentence and ban from public office for tax fraud in a case which could threaten the survival of the shaky coalition government.

If five top judges hand down the first definitive conviction to the four-times prime minister in dozens of court cases against him, it will mark the end of two decades in which he has dominated politics through his media power and political skill.

It could also plunge the government – an uneasy coalition of Enrico Letta’s center-left Democratic Party (PD) and Berlusconi’s center-right People of Freedom (PDL) – into crisis and bring renewed uncertainty to the euro zone third’s largest economy, with potential fallout right across the bloc.

The judges called a one-hour lunch adjournment on Tuesday after one of them delivered a summing up of the legal arguments and the judgments from two lower courts. After the break public prosecutor Antonello Mura will present his case.

Berlusconi’s chief lawyer, Franco Coppi, told journalists it was very unlikely the court would reach a decision on Tuesday because of other cases facing the judges. Experts say it could take as long as Thursday.

Coppi also said the defense would not request that the case be postponed until September – one possible outcome – although the judges might decide to do that on their own account.

Moderate politicians have urged the court to delay the ruling for the sake of political stability, due to the uncertain consequences if Berlusconi is convicted.

The judges of the Court of Cassation are hearing a final appeal by the 76-year-old media magnate against a four-year jail sentence, commuted to one year under an amnesty, and a five-year ban from office handed down by lower courts for the fraudulent purchase of broadcasting rights by his Mediaset media empire. Three other people were also convicted in the case.

If definitively convicted, Berlusconi would not normally go to prison because of his age but would have to do community service or serve his sentence at home.

Berlusconi accuses leftwing magistrates of abusing their powers to try to bring him down in more than two dozen court cases since he stormed to power for the first time in 1994.

The case was fast-tracked to be heard by a special summer session of the supreme court to avoid part of any sentence being annulled by the statute of limitations.

Although they are waiting for a signal from Berlusconi, PDL hawks have called for everything from a mass resignation of its government ministers to blocking Italy’s motorways if the court rules against him.

Fabrizio Cicchitto, a senior PDL parliamentarian, said the media magnate had faced 30 trials. “If this is not a political use of justice what is?”

The departure of Berlusconi from parliament if he is convicted would also raise major questions about the future of his party, which depends on his charisma and wealth.

A greater risk to the government could come from Letta’s faction-ridden PD, with many members already deeply unhappy about being in a coalition with their old enemy. Some may refuse to continue if he is found guilty.


However, both President Giorgio Napolitano, who dragged the parties into a coalition in April after a two-month crisis that followed inconclusive elections, and Letta himself are adamant that Italy cannot afford more instability as it struggles to climb out of its worst postwar recession.

Both major parties may be reluctant to precipitate an election that might produce an even more chaotic result than the February vote in which the populist 5-Star Movement of comedian Beppe Grillo surged to prominence.

Berlusconi has kept his party hawks on a tight leash for months, saying the government must continue. Political sources say this stance was influenced by his lawyers, keen to avoid upsetting the supreme court judges. The mercurial magnate’s reaction if he is found guilty is uncertain.

Berlusconi’s lawyers have filed 50 objections to the supreme court, which will rule only on legal procedure and whether the lower appeals court properly justified its sentence.

The court has three choices: convict Berlusconi, acquit him or send the case back to the appeals court due to legal errors.

Even if Berlusconi is found guilty, the ban from holding public office depends on a vote by his peers in the Senate which could take weeks or months.

The scandal-plagued mogul is also appealing in a lower court against a seven-year jail sentence in June for abuse of office and paying for sex with Moroccan-born nightclub dancer Karima El Mahroug, alias “Ruby the Heartstealer”, when she was underage.