Middle-east Arab News Opinion | Asharq Al-awsat

Iran says Snubbed by Six Powers on Nuclear Offer | ASHARQ AL-AWSAT English Archive 2005 -2017
Select Page

UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) – Iran’s U.N. ambassador said on Monday that six world powers have never responded to Tehran’s proposal for negotiations without pre-conditions aimed at resolving its nuclear stand-off with the West.

Instead, Iranian Ambassador Mohammad Khazaee told a meeting of the U.N. General Assembly, a small group of countries continued to insist that Iran halt its uranium enrichment program, a demand that he said violated international law.

“The 5+1 Group has yet to provide its response to Iran’s proposed package,” he said, referring to a proposal for talks delivered in May to the five permanent members of the U.N. Security Council and Germany.

“The policy of few powers in insisting on suspension as a precondition for negotiations bears zero relation to realities and is an irrational and failed policy,” Khazaee said.

He said that instead of imposing economic penalties on Tehran, which has been hit with three rounds of U.N. sanctions, “a solution that is based on realities … should be pursued.”

The proposal of Iran, which Western countries suspect is amassing the capability to produce atomic weapons under cover of a civilian nuclear energy program, was intended to counter the six powers’ offer of economic and political incentives in exchange for a suspension of enrichment work.

But the Iranian counter-offer to China, France, Germany, Russia and the United States ignored the Western demand for halting enrichment. U.S. and European officials dismissed the Iranian proposal and Russia has described it as disappointing, though the six never formally rejected it.


In the counterproposal, Iran called for cooperation to combat “common security threats” such as terrorism, “militarism” and drugs, and for developing international uranium enrichment consortiums in various countries, including Iran, to foster nuclear energy for development.

Tehran has suggested such a consortium on its soil before, ostensibly to defuse fears it might covertly divert enrichment technology to bomb-making. But Western powers have rejected the idea, mistrusting Iran over its record of nuclear secrecy.

Khazaee dismissed suggestions that Iran’s atomic ambitions were anything but peaceful and made clear that Tehran had no intention of compromising on the issue of uranium enrichment.

“The demand for the suspension of enrichment is illegal … and in contravention of the provisions of the NPT (nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty),” he said. “The Iranian nation will never accept illegal demands.”

Mohamed ElBaradei, director-general of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in Vienna, told the assembly his inspectors were not in a position to verify that Iran is not engaged in any secret nuclear activities.

In comments that echoed ones he made last month to the IAEA board of governors, ElBaradei said Iran should help the agency clarify intelligence reports alleging it had previously engaged in research on how to manufacture an atomic weapon.

Khazaee dismissed the intelligence reports, which the IAEA received from the United States and several other countries.

“What has been characterized as alleged studies (of nuclear weapons) are nothing but fabricated documents given to the agency by a certain country,” he said, adding that Tehran has never received copies of the intelligence reports.