Middle-east Arab News Opinion | Asharq Al-awsat

Asharq Al-Awsat book review: The road to Fatima gate - ASHARQ AL-AWSAT English Archive
Select Page

There are two ways to read this unusual book.

The first is as a thriller in which a daredevil reporter puts himself in harm’s way in search of the “inside story” of some of the most dangerous outfits in the world.

The second is as a penetrating portrayal of Lebanon’s fraught, and at the same time Quixotic, politics.

Michael J. Totten is an independent American reporter and political analyst who has covered events in such places as the Caucasus, the Balkans and, of course, the Middle East.

He seems to have chosen Lebanon as the subject of his new book because almost all the fault-lines of Middle Eastern politics are reflected in that small and vulnerable country.

At one level, Totten portrays Lebanon as part of the Islamic Republic’s glacis, and advance post in Iran’s indirect war against Israel. At another level, the Lebanon that emerges from Totten’s account is more than a just a pawn in the deadly game played by bigger regional powers in pursuit of their often conflicting interests.

Totten offers a portrait gallery of almost all key figures in Lebanese politics. It is amazing that almost all agreed to spend a lot of time with him and, in some cases, open their hearts to him as if he were an old friend. I specially liked the portraits of the Druze leader Walid Jumblatt and the Christian former militia commander Samir Geagea.

Jumblatt appears a disappointed and tired man who would, if he could, throw in the towel and retire to his mountain palace to read books by long discarded leftist writers. He tells Totten that the Syrians were responsible for the assassination of his father Kamal Jumblatt and that Hezbollah was capable of murdering him on orders from Tehran.

“Iranian flights to Beirut should be stopped,” Jumblatt tells Totten,” because Iranian flights may b e bringing money and arms” for Hezbollah.

Jumblatt also insists that “Iranian ambassador should be expelled.”

Jumblatt has all but abandoned his and his party’s “socialist” pretensions.

“The Socialist Jumblatt died a long time ago,” he says. “He died with my father. He had a dream with the leftist parties to change Lebanon. It was my father’s vision to change Lebanon. This is also one of the reasons he was killed. He was seen by the Arab world as backing Communists.”

In other words, Kamal Jumblatt’s assassination was part of Syrian Hafez al-Assad’s broader strategy of eliminating the leftist parties and leaders I both Syria and Lebanon.

Totten’s account of how the Syrian despot Bashar al-Assad humiliated Jumblatt is sharp and moving.

“Walid Jumblatt was next in line to make his pilgrimage to Damascus and apologize for resisting a regime that had killed his father, his friend Rafik Hariri, and so many more of his colleagues,” Totten writes. “Al-Assad made the ordeal as humiliating as possible and forced Jumblatt to all but beg for the privilege.”

To make matters worse, Hassan Nasrallah, the Hezbollah leader, publicly state that he had asked Damascus to let Jumblatt in.

Totten leaves Jumblatt with the impression that “the warlord in his castle was slowly but inexorably preparing his people for another surrender”, this time to Hezbollah.

Geagea is unashamedly on the right of the political spectrum and harbours no illusions about changing Lebanon. But, unlike Jumblatt, he is not prepared to surrender to anyone without a fight.

Totten portrays Geagea almost as a warrior- monk. Having spent years in prison after being convicted of murder, Geagea used the time to study Christianity, his religion by birth, in some depth. As a result, he claims, he learned to add “a spiritual dimension” to a life hitherto dominated by fighting.

Totten portrays the ex-General Michel Aoun, who heads the largest Christian bloc in the Lebanese parliament, as an egomaniac clown obsessed by the desire to become President of Lebanon.

At times the book sounds like a declaration of love for Lebanon. It is clear that Totten is smitten by the Lebanese culture in all its rich diversity.

Fatima Gate is the name of a village on the Lebanon-Israel border and thus a flashpoint of the 2006 mini-war that inflicted heavy losses on the Hezbollah without providing Israel with a clear-cut victory.

Totten shows that the mini-war was planned and managed by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, with the Lebanese branch of Hezbollah used as a local cover.

Totten depicts Tehran’s ambition to create an empire in the name of Islam.

He writes: “In the spring of 2010, Ayatollah Muhammad Bagher Kharrazi, head of the Iranian branch of Hezbollah boasted that Tehran would soon be the capital of anew ‘ Greater Iran’, which he called The Islamic United States. This new Persian Empire would stretch from Afghanistan to the Mediterranean and would necessitate the destruction of Israel.”

According to Totten, Lebanon would not gain a measure of freedom as a nation until regime change happens in both Iran and Syria.

On that score, Totten dismisses optimism “in the short run” but sounds optimistic in the medium and long-term.

“Totalitarian regimes are always self-defeating and temporary,” he declares.

Thus, both the Khomeinist regime and the rule of the Assad clan in Damascus are bound to come to an end.

Though written earlier this year, The Road to Fatima Gate was published at the start of the current popular uprising against Assad’s tyranny in Syria. Thus, Totten’s rejection of “optimism in the short- run” may sound premature. No one knows how the current revolt in Syria might end or where it might lead that key country. However, one thing is certain: the Assad clan has lost much of its power to dictate Lebanon’s policies.

Totten links “real peace” in Eastern Mediterranean to regime change in b the Iran and Syria.

He writes: “There will be real peace…. When citizens of Iran seize the levers of power, when al-Assad loses his control over Syria, and when Lebanon is the final home for all her children.”

Amir Taheri

Amir Taheri

Amir Taheri was the executive editor-in-chief of the daily Kayhan in Iran from 1972 to 1979. He has worked at or written for innumerable publications, published eleven books, and has been a columnist for Asharq Al-Awsat since 1987. Mr. Taheri has won several prizes for his journalism, and in 2012 was named International Journalist of the Year by the British Society of Editors and the Foreign Press Association in the annual British Media Awards.

More Posts